Tracking volunteer hours is just the beginning. If you're only reporting how many hours were served or how many volunteers showed up, you're missing the full story of your program’s impact. To effectively demonstrate value, build trust with stakeholders, and improve operations, you need to go deeper.

Whether you're presenting to your board, applying for grants, or sharing highlights with your community, tracking the right data helps you tell a compelling, results-oriented story. Here are five metrics that should be part of every volunteer program’s dashboard.

1. Volunteer Retention Rate

Why it matters: Retention is a powerful indicator of program health. When volunteers come back year after year, it typically signals positive experiences, meaningful work, and good communication.

How to measure it:
Divide the number of returning volunteers by the total number of volunteers from the previous year. This gives you a percentage that can guide engagement strategies.

Pro tip: Track by cohort or program type to see what’s working and where you may need to improve.

2. Average Volunteer Engagement Time

Why it matters: It's not just how many people show up, but how often and long they stay involved. This metric captures ongoing commitment and helps you identify your most active volunteers.

How to measure it:
Total hours served divided by the number of unique volunteers gives you the average engagement per volunteer. Use this data to forecast staffing needs and recognize high contributors.

Advanced tip: Layer in frequency of service to separate occasional volunteers from long-term supporters.

3. Volunteer Satisfaction Score

Why it matters: Engaged volunteers stay longer, contribute more, and are your best ambassadors. But you won't know how they’re feeling unless you ask.

How to measure it:
Use post-event or quarterly surveys to gather feedback on onboarding, role clarity, support, and overall experience. A simple Net Promoter Score (NPS) question like “How likely are you to recommend volunteering with us?” can reveal a lot.

Pro tip: Use AI tools in your volunteer management system to analyze open-text survey responses for trends and sentiment over time.

4. Impact-Based Outcomes

Why it matters: Volunteer hours are only meaningful when tied to real-world results. Funders, partners, and communities want to see outcomes that show progress and change.

How to measure it: Go beyond outputs (e.g., hours or participants) and focus on tangible impacts. For example:

• Lbs. of mulch laid = gallons of water saved through improved soil moisture retention
  (e.g., 1,000 lbs of mulch can save up to 25,000 gallons of water annually)
• Trees planted = pounds of carbon sequestered
  (e.g., one mature tree sequesters 48 pounds of carbon dioxide per year)
• Meals served = nutritional impact and food security improvements
• Trails maintained = increased community access to safe recreation

Even more important: Survey the recipients of your services. Ask them how volunteer-supported programs have impacted their lives. Are they safer, more supported, or more connected because of your work? Capturing these stories and outcomes adds vital qualitative data that funders love to see.

5. The Value of a Volunteer Hour

Why it matters: This single metric can dramatically increase the perceived financial impact of your program. Every hour your volunteers contribute has a dollar value that reflects wages saved and community contributions made.

How to measure it:
Each year, organizations like Independent Sector release updated estimates of the value of a volunteer hour. As of 2024, the national average was $31.80 per hour. Multiply that rate by your total volunteer hours to quantify your program’s return on volunteer investment (ROVI).

Pro tip: Update the value of a volunteer hour in your volunteer management software every year to ensure that automated reports and dashboards reflect the most current data.

Telling Your Story

Ultimately, these metrics help you go from “we had 50 volunteers last month” to “our volunteers helped divert 2,000 pounds of carbon, served 500 meals, and saved the city $45,000 in labor costs.” That’s the kind of story that resonates—with funders, with your community, and with your volunteers.

It also helps volunteers see the real impact of their time, making them more likely to return and bring others along with them.

Let’s Keep the Conversation Going

What’s your go-to metric for showing volunteer impact? Are you tracking outcomes you think others should know about? Share your thoughts in the comments or reach out—we’d love to hear how you're measuring what matters most.

‍